(Second Edition of the first volume of the journal, available at from Carnegie Mellon’s digital collection)
Prior to the professional scholarly journal system of today, there was only one major journal for American science, the American Journal of Science which still exists today and is focused on geology. In the nineteenth century, however, the journal focused on every scientific topic. The table of contents for the issues of the first volume (pictured) includes:
- Mineralogy, Geology & Topography
- Fossil Zoology
- Physics, Mechanics, & Chemistry
- Fine Arts
- Useful Arts
- Agriculture & Economics
Each article is roughly two to three pages and each contains an “intelligence” section which seems to be general news. This section continues into the twentieth century, when the journal was more focused on geology, but the intelligence section will talk about important findings of Physics & Chemistry, and other scientific areas.
The journal was founded by Benjamin Silliman and later edited by his son. There is a good overview of the foundation of the journal, and of course multiple references to it, but so far I have not been able to find any articles using a computational approach to analyzing its contents. In particular, I think it would be a great candidate for the topic modelling and query sampling techniques I have used earlier. I haven’t done much of this in the past (I intended to do so for the Journal of the American Chemical Society), but this journal may even be a good candidate for a network analysis since it would contain a large number of scientists in the United States and potentially would show the network as it was beginning to split into different disciplines. Fortunately, there is also over 100 years of textual data available for this journal in the public domain, making it a potentially very rich source. I am going to see if some initial tests may get some interesting results, and I’m looking forward to seeing whether this journal helps understand the professionalization of science and the origins of the scholarly communication system in even more interesting ways than the Journal of the American Chemical Society has done so far.